Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Lourdes Trujillo
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Girlfriend of a rock singer. Someone's been putting up bunches of information about this band and their girlfriends: Nick Gigler, Lydia Wilson, Joel Madden, The Movielife, Lola's...Perhaps the band is notable, perhaps the leader is, but the fiancee and girlfriend of one or another? The clothing line the girlfriend of one started? I don't quite think so... --jpgordon {gab} 00:20, 19 Oct 2004 (UTC)
- Delete this, along with Lydia Wilson and Lola's. Definitely keep Joel Madden, and maybe keep Nick Gigler and The Movielife, not sure about those. Everyking 00:52, 19 Oct 2004 (UTC)
- Delete all but Joel Madden. Not notable, and we don't need to reward a fan. I'd rather see even the Joel Madden stuff folded into Good Charlotte, but it's not requisite . Geogre 19:37, 19 Oct 2004 (UTC)
- Keep all. anthony (see warning) 23:23, 23 Oct 2004 (UTC)
- Deleting any person whose notability is second hand only seems good at first take, but I would think there needs to be a line drawn, so we don't delete for instance Mary Todd or Yoko Ono. I think keep the band members and unless they are notable in some other way than being the girlfriend of a musician, delete the girlfriends, at most they deserve a mention in the article on the musician they are dating. But caution against phrases like "is the girlfriend" or "is dating", as those will be dated references, prefer "began dating in 2004" as that will remain true even in 2100
- Keep all - David Gerard 07:12, 24 Oct 2004 (UTC)