Wikipedia:Cleanup

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by Andre Engels (talk | contribs) at 12:36, 17 March 2004. The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

Jump to navigation Jump to search


Front Matter

Please read Wikipedia:Cleanup process for instructions on maintaining this page.

Sample terms to use

keep - fine - nonsense - OK now? - unimproved - insufficient - meta - asdfjkl - stubified - substub - expand - nonexistent - obscure - idiosyncratic - advert - selfpromotion - ungrammatic - ????? - silly - joke - repeat - link - chatty - rant - POV - NPOV - copyvio - brilliant - obscenity - blog - vanity page...

  • Most comments here are first impressions, not considered analyses of an article. Thinking deeply before listing an article here is not discouraged, but it is definitely not a requirement either.
  • Limit comments to a few words only; verbose comments will be edited for brevity!
  • New entries go at the top.
  • Begin your comments with a "-" to separate it from the previous one, but:
    • If you have made or are reporting a change to the page in question, Use a "+" instead (e.g. "+ fixed the first paragraph", "+ deleted" or "+ stubbified")
  • The comment "delete" or "VFD" is a vote to move this page to VfD, not to delete it immediately. Please list such entries in bold.
  • If you think an article meets the criteria for speedy deletion, write "delete immediately".
  • Edit conflicts can be mitigated by copying your own text before you submit it, so you can paste and repost it quickly.
  • Old listings can be moved as appropriate to Wikipedia:Pages needing attention or Wikipedia:Duplicate articles, or just marked as stubs
    Sign with your sig only—no timestamp please (to do this, type -- ~~~)


JUST IN

March 17

King Zhuangxiang of Qin - NPOV, wikify Muriel

Copland - I have NO idea what this is. Merovingian ↕ Talk

Shortcut for Cross Product - unwikified, looks like a term paper, too. Merovingian ↕ Talk

Athletics at the 1980 Summer Olympics - one sentence. I'm sure more happened than is worth one sentence. Graham  :) | Talk

Sardaar - is this true? I've heard it used as a first name, but not as a slang term. It's an orphan anyway so vfd if not verifiable -- Graham  :) | Talk

Diaspora language needs, well, everything. Graham  :) | Talk

Euronat - seems POV (re: "fascist") --CeltMDC

Quantum number -- needs lots of work

What goes around comes around - possibly incorporate content into List of clichés and then vfd?

White fly - needs wikified, not NPOV, possible vfd or complete rewrite --CeltMDC

Wharton Fellows - stub, unwikified, lack of context, possibly vanity, possibly vfd --CeltMDC

Charlie on the MTA - Could be useful if it has some folk value in Boston. Anybody? jengod

Jesuit High School - should be a disambiguation page; needs to address that there are multiple Jesuit High Schools, and what they are.

Flex Dollars - should go to vfd unless someone wants to rewrite (and possibly rename) into an article about the general concept.

Manas - needs work

James Plaskett ???

Magahi - context? Fuzheado

Luxottica - one liner, not much. Fuzheado

Craft Unionism - quality, just needs a good wikification

Heterotransplant - needs editing, too many "maybe".

Islamic views of homosexuality - The bizarre stuff removed by Sam Spade has been lying in this article for about 8 months: can someone do a fact-check of this article? The material was apparently part of an otherwise sensible-looking edit by User:Silver Maple.

James_Lehrer - stub

March 16

Canadian federal election, 1925 - Formatting & possibly POV.

Renal failure -- Has blank sections marked as "section to be filled", no editing since 7 Aug 2003. Silverfish

Galling -- looks more like a dictionary entry than an encyclopedia entry

Bad - merge with evil?

Residual current circuit breaker -- can someone fact-check this?

Maria Pia de Saxe-Coburg-Gotha-Braganca, House of Braganza - advocacy pieces for a pretender to a royal title which is at best dubious.

Pseudobranch don't understand as stands

Institute for Effective Therapy of Homosexuality - currently orphan, merge with International Healing Foundation? --CeltMDC

International Healing Foundation needs massive NPOV treatment also -- PlatinumX - I disagree, see talk page Karl Naylor

Jack R. Lousma - data dump of unwikified text from public domain site

Ancient Slime - lack of context, needs wikifying, possible vfd --CeltMDC


Messali Hadj - needs explanation of TLAs

Public Interest Research Groups - needs wikifying. --CeltMDC

Japanese translation note trans. should be standard, possible vfd? -- PlatinumX

Pwnage - conjugation of verb pwn used in online gaming. Unnecessary - DavidWBrooks

March 15

Cork (city) - Second city of Ireland. Deserves more, surpassed by Limerick, Galway, etc. Zoney

Hartley oscillator - Could probably do with expanding, mostly (in-effect) bullet points.Silverfish - the bullet point material is paraphrasing the bottom of this page

Arthur Eichengrün needs checking the facts and wikifying. --Palapala 21:46, 2004 Mar 15 (UTC) + I took a shot at it. Fact check on talk. Ok now? Lupo 12:42, 16 Mar 2004 (UTC)

Megalodon - all rather dubious.+Now a verifiable stub.

German literature -- needs intro/abstract and links to existing articles.

Seto Kaiba, Obelisk the Tormentor -- incomprehensible Yi-Gi-Oh something-or-others

Sverre Sjölander, talk page claims it is a vanity, vfd?

Surds and Indices, no content. | Now brief intro + specific brief into on surds. Next someone do how to manipulate surds. Zoney

Sukhdev Singh Babbar, POV, lacking context

Stanislav Petrov, unwikified, copyvio?

CSI: Crime Scene Investigation - needs NPOVing & gush-ectomy

Richard Lyons - not much here -- Fuzheado

Didaktik - needs wikifying -- Cyrius

Mike Powell - needs wikifying -- Fuzheado

Orixa - substub -- Khym Chanur + Sent to Orisha; was blanked when I saw it. (Smerdis of Tlön)

March 14

Tourism - many of the external links seem to be advertising

Root locus - unwikified, sub-stub, unintellible

Reelin - unwikified, orphan, content questioned in article

Redemption of First-born - lacking context, orphan

Ransom Everglades - POV, chatty, unwikified, unencyclopedic

Babi Yar needs a lot of work. --Palapala

March 13

Technology acceptance model unwikified, orphan, copyvio?

Pain of Salvation - passes the Google test but needs complete rewrite.

Dark Frith -is this even true? -- Seth Ilys - I can't remember it and it doesn't seem right to me, google brings up no hits for "dark frith" with "watership down". Graham  :) | Talk

Michael Anissimov - stub, info needs verification

Mazda Miata - reads like an ad (not as bad as others I've read on Wiki, but pretty bad)

Candomble Ketu author obviously needs help

Colt Python - Needs wikifying, probably NPOV and formatting.

Museum of Jurassic Technology - reads like a copyvio, plus doesn't explain just WHAT the museum holds

Chem Trails huh? doesn't explain what it is - a word for Contrails I think?

No, it's tinfoil hattery. Usually spelled without a space, "chemtrails." Contrails in fact show an enormous variation in appearance. Chemtrail conspiracy theorists assert that certain kinds of appearance cannot possibly be contrails, and represent high-altitude spraying of unidentified chemicals for nefarious purposes. Dpbsmith 23:16, 14 Mar 2004 (UTC)
indeed, but tinfoil hattery that still gets a mention on the bottom of contrails :((

Abu-Dahr - unwikified, probably needs NPOV.

Thomas S. Wootton High School unencyclopedic style. This high school is well-known in my area.

Gehyra mutilata - unwikified, POV?

Diane Dufresne - needs work

Battlefield:1942 modifications - I assume this is about a game?

Aptitude - Laughably stubby.

Slovenske telekomunikacie - very POV. unsalvagable? - Removed POV/Expanded stub/Renamed

Scotland Yard (band) - Ancient sub stub.

Wahlau Can this ever be more than a dict. def?

Wanksta unwikified, dict def, orphan

Wes Linster unwikified, important?

Wharton Fellows, lacking content, format

White fly unwikified, is a product review, copyvio?

Self-destruct - Only talks about Star Trek and "self-destruct". Could do with references to real life self destruct buttons and instances (such as NASA space probes etc). Nick04 22:17, 13 Mar 2004 (UTC)

Computer numbering formats - very long article, lots un-wikified. Much info needs redistributed to constituent topics Binary numeral system, Integer (computer science), Floating point, ASCII, Binary coded decimal and Data type. Removed a request to merge with Integer (computer science). See Talk page. Zoney

Brigid Berlin - looks messy, some POV

MediaWiki:Cults - POV and inaccurate

Mind control needs copyed for clarity

God of the gaps - POV

Aria of chianti classico - not an article

Attribute - far more than just a telecommunications term

Ad hoc protocol list needs some kind of description of what is on it. At the moment all I can see is that it is a list Andre Engels

Some kind of description added by Tagishsimon

March 12

Leg it dict def. vfd?

Germanic migrations is incoherent, possibly POV. moink - Partially merged and redirected to Migrations Period, which needs help as well, but is better. (Smerdis of Tlön)

EotE2004 - looks like potentioal copyvio. needs wikifying anyway. - source material: delete (Smerdis of Tlön)

Nucleoid region - substub (one sentence) - needs expanding - if subject worth including Silverfish

Broadband ISDN - needs merge and rediect with B-ISDN

Beyond the Veil - substub -- Khym Chanur

Red Apple Cigarettes - can this ever be a useful article? vfd?

Cojones - dict def. vfd?

March 11

Frank O'Connor currently in point form, don't know who he is enough to fix. moink

Zoran Zivkovic (politician) needs wikification, formatting, love. moink

Core competence -- needs wikification, npov from someone who can distinguish pov from npov in this case. moink

Dastar Corp. v. Twentieth Century Fox Film Corp. was on VfD; wikified, needs copyed to be reader friendly

Baul - I get the impression that English is not the first language of this page's creator + has been updated, still a bit substubby though

Catholic Youth Organization - Major language cleanup needed

Low-key lighting needs wikifying

42 BELOW: advert -- Khym Chanur

National War Labor Board: substub -- Khym Chanur

Serbia - needs wikifying and language cleanup

Iberian-Caucasian languages - probably should be moved back to Caucasian languages, & perhaps Iberian-Caucasian languages a separate stubbish article, but a trained linguist should decide

Dance Improvisation doesn't tell you exactly what it is--could be much clearer.

GOSPLAN - needs punching up

Pacific Science Center - for starters, where is this? Also wikify. moink + wikified, needs content and fact checking Richard cocks

Maureen Lipman - lacking content

Hacker's Manifesto - valid topic but on VfD

March 10

Krishna Deva Raya - pov pov pov. copyvio?

Carpenter bee Nice picture, but no actual content Silverfish

Borrow pit - sub-stub (one sentence) - just definition, and perhaps not a very clear one. Silverfish + expanded a bit and linked to Gravel pit (similar concept) Paul W

Batch processing - needs wififying, and possibly more context given. Silverfish Wikified now but needs more content - e.g. DOS batch file? Zoney

Chess and mathematics has little content. -Chess and music similarly needy

Massively Multiplayer Online Persistent World - mess - cumbersome - stub - orphan +made new article on same topic @ massively multiplayer online game, this now redirs there Mrwojo

March 9

Gilman reagent. My head is about to explode. Context please.

Franking privilege - needs serious expanding, clarification of which elected officials have this privilege

Eugenics War - needs wikifying

Myths over the GDR - babelfish translation, seems POV at first look

this article has been posted many times to the german wikipedia, but it has been deleted every time, perhaps the author now tries en:. Have a lot of fun ;-)

March 8

Tony Kaye - need wikification

Meditative art: needs grammar and format work, wikified

Status - dicdef, looks like a Wiktionary entry -Wikibob

Joseph Shearin important? - this was added by User:Isis (K. Kay Shearin); it is her ancestor. no importance

Joni Dourif pseudoscience, self-promotion

Jonathan Zittrain famous?

Tiger hash function: needs grammar cleanup, filling in

Exotic Probability: are parts of this a spoof? Checking needed. - Looks clean to me. A whack of solid Google hits on Feynman and negative probability. Denni No, it's a carefully-constructed hoax, I believe Charles Matthews

March 7

Hancock Place - needs NPOVing

Steven Soliah - any article that starts Steven Soliah is not... needs cleaning up. Article doesn't read very well.

Mickey Hart - somewhat surprising that this page has existed in such a poor state since 25 Jul 2002...+Yikes! You were right. I gave it a copy edit and expansion, but it could still use more work. heidimo 15:18, 9 Mar 2004 (UTC)

Potassium deficiency - a photo/diagram would be welcome. Pfortuny

Balancing network - needs in-depth description and a bit of non-engineers-only text. Pfortuny

Bob Marley needs NPOV. heidimo

HMS Temeraire (1907) - empty. Pfortuny

List of alternative, speculative and disputed theories - Needs NPOV cleanup, listed on VfD

Atlanta Child Murders needs NPOV, wikify. moink + NPOV'd and partially wikified, but now inelegant -- Karl Naylor - also needs additional info on perpetrator (currently not even name) and extensive grammar/syntax edit

Frida (movie) POV gushing movie review that got undeleted without due process. RickK 05:21, 7 Mar 2004 (UTC)

Cabrini-Green - needs NPOVing

Counseling is a vaguely hostile stub. heidimo 03:37, 7 Mar 2004 (UTC)

March 6

Gonzalo Ximenes de Quesada - needs major wikification.

Archie comics: Could somebody suggest where to move this to? It's certainly not on it's intended (i.e. linked-to) topic. moink -> Sonic the Hedgehog? DJ Clayworth

Hüsker Dü needs NPOVing. Meelar

Interesting and uninteresting numbers - VfD asap, although it is a (silly) redirection now. Pfortuny

Food and cooking hygiene - VfD Pfortuny - A short but important article. People die because these rules aren't followed. Perhaps move to Wikipedia:How to (food prep) Denni.

  • I have created a new article foodborne illness. Maybe I will later find time to do something on good hygiene practice? David Thrale 00:28, 17 Mar 2004 (UTC)

Tombolo - a photo would be nice here. Pfortuny

Bugge Wesseltoft needs NPOV, wikification. moink + worse, it seems copyrighted. Content removed and note put on user and talk pages -- Karl Naylor 12:03, 7 Mar 2004 (UTC)

triose, pentose, hexose - should all be under the same title and probably include a diagram. Pfortuny

Mario Benedetti - quite poor as it is for his fame. Pfortuny

Abdel-Razak al-Yehiyeh - old page, needs updating since July 2002

Salam Faiad - old page, needs updating since July 2002

Short fiction by Stephen King - lacking something. Too many red links.

Information warfare - still needs serious editing for POV. Washington irving

Sputnik 2 - a diagram/photo would be nice. Pfortuny

Trace fossil - quite poor. Pfortuny

Diyala River - a map would be most welcome. Pfortuny

Nuclear Silo (StarCraft), Refinery (StarCraft), and so on... see what links to StarCraft. - Quite poor. I'd rather delete them but. Pfortuny -I believe allowing an article of this type sets a danherous precedent. Wikipedia is not a game preserve. Suggest VfD. Denni

Tetracyclic antidepressant - probably a chemical diagram would come in handy. Also a bit deeper would be welcome. Pfortuny

Late Imperial China - surely deserves something longer. Pfortuny

The Source - needs general cleaning

Jacek Skalmierski - a person or software or both?

Corinth, Greece needs to be divided between into 2 articles: one about the city, the other about the prefecture llywrch

March 5

Little Three needs context; unwikified, unencyclopaedic

Battle of Lepanto (1500) - just one small fact on a battle participant - that's not even the right battle, Cervantes was in the Battle of Lepanto (1571)

Ocean University of China - wikify. moink

L'Aquila may be a machine translation? Needs work & wikification. moink

VEISHEA needs wikification, formatting, organization. moink

U.S.-North Korea relations has PD text added (top of article). I consider this not suitable fro Wikipedia (POV), can anyone check out, please? Kokiri 22:10, 5 Mar 2004 (UTC)

List of Vietnamese companies - huge text dump (as credited). May not be copyright viol (source asserts no copyright), but needs much work to be an article. - Delete? Just 105 pages of companies, not necessarily ones we want articles on anyway.

How to care for a pet cockatoo was listed on VfD consensus to keep byt needs TLC

Microsoft antitrust case -- NPOV

March 4

Unification shoes - not unsure enough about this to post on vfd.  ??? + info is valid, but it's still a bit sub stubby

Korandje -- wikify, clarify

Methodological relativism - needs everything.

Sebastiao Salgado - might or might not be important, links to a language i don't understand. moink

The 20th Century in Review content, wikification & NPOV needed

Dormant Commerce Clause needs to be merged with Commerce Clause by someone with an interest in U.S. Constitution.

Transwiki:Zazaki needs to be moved to the mainspace after it is wikified. See m:transwiki

Sowing Ancient text with little if any relevance today.

Doordarshan Huh? Needs context, fmt, wiki--the works

Edgar Meyer - new article needs NPOV. moink

Arthur Gould - decent article, needs fact checking that I can't do (I know nothing about rugby football) also needs some copyediting. PMC

March 1 - March 3

Samuel Renshaw - poor stub, one line bio.

Intellectual property education Probably needs self promotion removed as does perhaps presumed autobio Shaheen Lakhan; Human memory process by same IP (noted at #February 4, 11th item), and those labelled "(Top)" at Contribs of (surely) the same person are also not yet edited by others, and may (or not!) still deserve scrutiny

Folk_music - This is no way NPOV. It's one particular, very persuasive, and often-argued POV, but Louis Armstrong has his supporters (myself amongst them).

Marshall Rosenberg - NPOVing due -some done, mainly by removing vast swaths of fawning. Needs someone who knows about peace & conflict resolution to take a look.

Mid-levels - Formatting

Mamba - the text here is extremely minimal, appears to contain a misspelling I'm hesitant to correct, and is about the black mamba rather than mambas in general

List of British Columbia Premiers - Table colors need help.

Steven Hawley - uniwified text dump (from public domain site, so not a copyvio) + I did what I could. Need better formating Quinwound 06:15, Mar 3, 2004 (UTC)

HMS Tireless (S88) - poor stub

Fred Tuttle - npov problems, define why he is significant (won 1998 GOP senatorial primary...)

Eliezer Ben-Yehuda - see talk page, not in standard format and POV

March 2

The Theory of Everything - ???

KPPP - substub

Thutmose I of Egypt - birth date makes no sense, German entry has altogether different dates

Religion in the United States - needs copyed

Steve Rochinski - poor stub

Wikipedia:Searching#Wildcards - an "I don't know how this works" answer

Danny Rolling - idiosyncratic, check facts, rewrite

March 1

Juicer - repetitive, needs heavy rephrasing

Lardal - poor stub, delete if can't be fixed.

The Delinquents - needs more info

TradeStation - poor stub

Battle of Freiburg - substub +replaced with correct stub (was about Battle of Freiberg anyway)

River - data given for ten longest rivers frequently doesn't match the data given on the actual page for that river.

Vladimir Akopian and David Janowski - needs expanding by someone who knows chess.

Abaris the Hyperborean - I don't understand what this is about - seems POV but might be quoting someone (but who?) - what's the connection between the article and the title? Andre Engels + Probably ought to be merged with Abaris, not sure why there are two articles (Smerdis of Tlön)

Aaron J. Fink unwikified, POV tract

Alpine butterfly bend context, lacking content

Ramification problem substub, no clue what's about - Nonsense, delete immediately --Faradn - not nonsense, just a wafer-thin AI stub

sound pressure needs verifikation and eventually merging with stuff in Acoustics by someone who knows about accoustics acoustics

February 25-29

Japanese pottery - unwikified, contains several untranslated Japanese language terms

Animation:Master - reads like an advert

Allan R. Bomhard - nothing more than a list of works, unwikified

Ammunition for infantry - only discusses subject circa 1911

Irish fiddling - unencyclopedic sub-stub

Physical property - Scrappy and neglected

Kakeru - needs a touchup

Art journal - lacking content

Arthur Gold - unwikified, obscure sports terminology

Arch Revision Control System - lacking context, unwikified, incomprehensible

Arbitrary - dictionary def.

Chairman of the National Defence Committee of North Korea - bogus crap, Kim Jong-il is not head of state

St. Mary's, Maryland -- needs wikif.

Todaiji temple - microStub

Kazuo Matsui - stub, needs more info

Shiso - Features many names of foreign dishes that need explanation.

USS Barney (DDG-6) - stub, could use table/picture of ship

Friedrich Nietzsche - final section "Misc" ends in what appears to be a tangential essay with no clear connection to Nietsche's ideas -- llywrch

Digital physics - unformatted, fringe theory?

February 28

System Shock - needs NPOV

Ratcliffe - strange unformated text dump. No google match to sample text. Salvagable, or vfd?

Auberon Herbert - lacking context, deadend

Mark_Hucko vanity?

LinuxQuestions.org - advert, not article

Penultimate - dict def.

Paddywagon - questionable accuracy, orphan, dict def. Make real article or delete

February 27

Ganglati - made it a little bigger, needs more info and could be rewritten

Claude Gauvreau - needs language editing, NPOVing, and TLC.

Hans Zwieidneck von Sudenhorst - needs formatting

Fernando Lopes - needs formatting

The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire - Is the title correct? (My copy is different.) Also, article does not even touch on the theme of this influential book: the fall of the Roman Empire. llywrch

Listing removed from Wikipedia:Speedy deletions: Vroman's Bookstore is a popular bookstore in Southern California. However, it needs a lot of work.

List of Presidents of Somaliland - it needs frmt, it's not a software bug.

Jugemu - NPOV, fmt

Every Little Thing - NPOV

Setsubunn -cleanup

Tak Matsumoto -cleanup

Dahrumasan ga Koronda - needs wikifying

Imperial Japanese Army - political rant

Bregenz - parts of it could benefit from list format

Blueball - unwikified, orphan. Similar article had already been deleted from Blueballs (also orphan). Make into an article or delete.

Siamese coup d'état of 1932 - unwikified, possibly copyright issues? + working on it (but not finished yet), grammar to bad for copyvio

February 26

Thomas Oliver for Power Rangers fans.

Planned obsolescence - slanted, thin, disorganized +reorganized, partially NPOVed; article was about all types of obs. so I moved it ike9898 + revised lead-in to remove POV Denni

Non-Christian perspectives on Jesus - listed on VfD Feb 20 to Feb 26, issue is now round naming of the article rather than existence of the article itself. See its talk page.

Al-Nakba Palestinian propaganda pov.

Marmorosphax - nearly empty stub (same type as Notoscincus)

Notoscincus - put in info and a website with more information for someone else

Gallery Fake - wikify, reword

Tourism of Argentina - expand, context, wikify, npov

History of Socialism: Part 2-subheadings but no content.Saul Taylor

February 25

International Meridian Conference. Wikisource?

List of important news web sites Wikipedia is not a web directory

Communication source - dictionary definition

Booya - mess

Stew - bad dic def

Creature - accuracy disputed

February 20-24

Biff Tannen - copyedit and wikification needed, as well as general style adjustments

A - The article contains @s instead of special forms of the letter A. It seems to derive from the scan of the 1911 Encyclopedia Brittanica, so it would probably be an easy fix for someone with access to the paper version.

5.45mm caliber - short

Type 21 frigate - only content is two msg-statements. Pico-Stub? I think this is under construction. DJ Clayworth - A bunch of such formulaic sub-stubs by this author

Tanaka Memorial - It's just a collection of links...

Codex Sinaiticus - prob. ESL damage

Le charme discret de la bourgeoisie - first-person film review that has been here since October.

Wah Mee Massacre - if these trials were so high profile, can we got some detail on them?

February 23

MMR vaccine - NPOV probs, see page's talk

Interconnection - dic def

Normanton, Derby City accuracy?

Serous - dictionary definition

Southwestern Somalia - vague article attempt... is it a nation or not? Under what definition?

Lamina propria - dictionary definition

Slipmat - dictionary definition

Southern All Stars - messy

Scavenger - substub. Added a few linked examples and a msg:stub - MPF

Rumination - substub

Discordant - dict. def.

Robert C Craig - orphan

Urban guerrilla -- new, only contains a link, but could be developed -- BCorr ¤ Брайен

February 22

Inspiration expiration -dictionary definitions

Too Short - is it too short? +stub. - yep. VfD. Denni

Fremskrittspartiet - 2nd paragraph needs work, as it is vague and possibly POV.

Tensor derivative no content; just see alsos

Deadpool - substub; minor comic character.

Cel-shading - substub, needs more on how process works --Faradn

3G, WCDMA, CDMA2000, FOMA, TD-SCDMA - laughably small for such a popular tech topic -- Fuzheado

Radiation protection stub; needs content.

United World Colleges, Atlantic College wikif.

February 21

Biosensor, Nondisjunction, resort -sub stub definitions; need trans to Wiktionary and then expansion.

Police procedure - needs rename to "police procedural"; inbound links need updating +sj+

Napoleonic medal - substub

Minatitlán - substub; unwikif.

Iain Cameron - substub; unwikif.

Southern Levant massive block of unwikified text; +wikified, but more about archeology than Levant, perhaps condense?

Thrill of a Lifetime - unwikified

February 20

Forage Stub; links to five types of forage; better content on three of those five pages.

Telephone - Mess of "related articles" needs subdivision in some orderly manner. (Excellent article cluster; overall revision also needed -- article could be better divided into paragraphs and topics; move to PNA when "related articles" is cleaned up +sj+)

Began the process of re-working this article. The actual content in the history section was mostly a massive quote from a circa 1900 project Gutenberg book (Heros of the Telegraph) -- the article needs an introduction which describes what a telephone IS, and some discussion of the various types... Then, we need LINKS to sub-pages for telephone(history) and telephone(signaling) and telephone(Switching). The basic link cluster at the bottom is EXCELLENT.... it's the stuff on the telephone ITSELF that sucks. Rick Boatright 16:19, 1 Mar 2004 (UTC)

Fundamental Laws - sub-stub; needs more context.

Raiffeisen stub; confusing? see the talk page. Lupo

MUD trees. Undeleted, clean. Possible copyright issues. See Talk:MUD trees

Gene duplication + Many of User:Dmb000006's substubs merged by Lexor

February 19

VFD for Anjali - Somesh

Kronhausen, Phyllis & Eberhard, misnamed, lacking content, unwikified, orphan; delete? rename? +sj+

Patty Stonesifer cpvio?; lightly wikified press release

drug addiction is currently undergoing some massive edits.

List of English competitions add to list! only one item.

List of Internet stations (Radio, TV) needs expansion. Could use some formatting, possibly merging with the (template for) the list of ordinary stations.

KOMPILER - another jargon filled FOLDOC entry

KMODEL - needing context, lacking content

Cash flow statement - unwikified, need fact checking, rewording. (Added some introductory content --Meara)

Escuela Moderna - sub-stub

Equality of outcome - stub; just a quotation.

Neoseps - + de-stubbed. But there are hundreds of such stubs— just go to Skink and click on any species link! automatically generated.

Lists of cities by country, most with only a coupld of cities: from the break-up of list of cities. Please help expand them.

Ecuador, El_Salvador, the Gambia, Hungary, Jordan, Moldov, Panama, Paraguay, Somalia, Macedonia, Venezuela, Zambia, Zimbabwe


Ted Husing - not copyvio, but needs wikifying and editing

ISO_3166-2:AR, ISO_3166-2:EC, ISO_3166-2:ES, ISO_3166-2:KG, ISO_3166-2:TJ, ISO_3166-2:TL, ISO_3166-2:UZ, ISO_3166-2:YE

these each need a link to subnational entites

Iraqi opposition - update? stub.

Image retrieval - needs update, wikif.

Flighted pet parrots - who wants to make an article out of this? rename to Pet parrots, link from species-listing page Parrots?

February 16-18

War Crimes committed by Israel during the Al-Aqsa Intifada. + Moved to Accusations against Israel of war crimes during the Al-Aqsa Intifada, and orphaned redirects deleted. still prolly POV; only one major author.

STS-93 - Good start; needs some copyediting

Guillermo Lora - I don't understand all this splitting, and where and why comes Argentina in? It's about some Trotzkyist leader in Bolivia. Lupo

Petrus Plancius - sub-stub Isomorphic

Mark Satin - resume style mini-bio. needs npov, reduction, formatting and fleshing out.

Culture of Liechtenstein. This might be accurate. Needs work.

Edwin Thanhouser - stub; =no context

February 17

Light Poetry - link farm; rename/merge with Doggerel? Linked only from Poetry, as a verse form.

Soufflé - pls transwiki this recipe 'how-to' appropriately.

Bokharaby -- merge with Bessarabia?

Guthlac - somebody's homework: an essay containing first person singular and plural. Needs major cleanup by someone familiar with Old English poetry. Lupo

Homer Lea - great bio; needs fact-checking, NPOV, dates filled in

Donny Hamzik - related to Manowar; stub; needs context.

List of Croatians - Most linked pages need copyediting, as do the pages about Croation locations. Needs fact checking by non-anonymous Croatian w'pedians; much anon contrib. Check also for exactly duplicated entries with slightly different spelling or phrases in the title that shd be redirects.

Practical equine psychology needs wikif. +copyvio warning

Fusient Media Ventures - fmt, NPOV if that's (excuse my POV) possible w. WWF wrestling... Denni

Bob Smith -- stub; needs dates.

The Sun Don't Lie - needs album fmt

War All the Time - needs album fmt; NPOV.

Paralus sub-stub. needs context.

Toto (actor) - +wik, detail; Duplicates [[Tot%F2]] -144.138.194.169; still needs work.

February 16

Three ball cascade. A how-to. Should this be on wikibooks?

Practice. Was on VfD. See Talk:Practice

Kay Petre - +wik, still needs fmt

Brockhaus - needs work

1920 in Germany, 1921 in Germany, 1922 in Germany - incredible amounts of info with no subheads and humongous paragraphs; maybe some unacademicizing editing needed, too

Slamball - +much editing, still needs help, esp. on "Teams" section

An American Werewolf in London - someone's personal movie review.

February 11-15

Medical decision making sub-stub; no content; all but orphaned; delete/merge with Decision making. +sj+

Ibo needs deletion/merging w/Igbo for context, clarification. See Talk:Igbo for more.

Probability and statistics substub removed from VfD, with many keep votes. More refs needed.

Mike Herrera, Tom Wisniewski, Yuri Ruley - just bullet lists now

ISO 3166-2:AZ, ISO 3166-2:BD, ISO 3166-2:BJ, ISO 3166-2:BY, ISO 3166-2:CN, ISO 3166-2:DE, ISO 3166-2:DO, ISO 3166-2:ER, ISO 3166-2:ET, ISO 3166-2:FI, ISO 3166-2:GE, ISO 3166-2:ID, ISO 3166-2:JP, ISO 3166-2:KZ, ISO 3166-2:LA, ISO 3166-2:MD, ISO 3166-2:MU, ISO 3166-2:MY, ISO 3166-2:NL, ISO 3166-2:NO, ISO 3166-2:SI, ISO 3166-2:TM, ISO 3166-2:TW

Could use links to the related article about the subnational entities, needs ''', possibly an update to the (a bit too uniform) introduction, rm stub notice?

Ignipuncture needs wikif.

1921 Plebiscite in Silesia and Korfanty led violence - title makes no sense, article begins in mid-stream with no context. Needs work

Federal Protective Service substub.

Abdul Wahab Effendi sub-stub; no context

Back-choir sub-stub. needs wikif.

February 14

Reinhard Heydrich incomplete, should mention Reichssicherheitshauptamt RSHA Andries

xa context? not clear at all -- Mrdice

Register — needs to be made in to a disambiguation page, with separate articles for the different meanings. —Noldoaran (Talk)

Unifying conjecture - Actually just verbosity, candidate for Vfd Charles Matthews

History of perpetual motion machines copyvio issues need to be checked by someone who knows about it more than i do

Chemical property mess.

Induction hob. Context please? What's it do?

Marvin Camel - pov

Hollywood cycles - stub. Zoe and I both wonder to what extent this is a term of art. Needs clearer explanation if so.

Ricochet the article seems fine, but it should be moved to Ricochet(Half-Life-Mod) and replaced by a disambig page (see it's "what links here"). We also should check weather Ricochet(Psychology) or something related exists and if not create a stub. I'm too tired for something that complicated Lady Tenar

Jenna Morasca - could be merged with the Survivor article and made into a redirect - Which Survivor article? She could be redirected to three of them. RickK + I added the links, but I think the article should be deleted MK

February 13

Yiyang - every section just one sentence often stating not really special things.

User interface engineering - needs more

Starving Time of 1610 - needs more, or merging somewhere

Siege of Viana - not an article yet

Annunaki - am mess for a gamester to fix. Bmills

Chief Joseph - The timeline is pretty fractured. Jumps from 1863 to 1877, back to 1871, up to 1877, back to 1873, the finally to 1877 and continues as it should. - Rbs

Toledo Reforms - wikify and clarify

Origin of Aztec term to refer to the Mexica - can any pre-Columbian expert see a way of redeeming this? If it can't be improved soon it's a candidate for speedy deletion on grounds of absence of content, etc. seglea

February 12

Surface energy is incomprehensible. Context please! Meelar

Student loan needs info on places other than the US

Culture of Liechtenstein - needs some actual content.

Frankie Laine. A mess. Possibly created by Michael. - it's him --Mrdice 18:46, 2004 Feb 13 (UTC)

Tricycle (World War II) is hard to understand, needs context. Meelar

Walt Disney - too long - no table of contents. + Some work done on subheadings.

Modulo - deserves better + I think I've improved the slang definition. Anything else? - Expanded, but whole redirected modular arithmetic page is now trying to do three things at once

Wizo. Needs work.

Venedes - uh? Can anyone make sense of this? About Wends, no? Good idea to merge and save anything useable about the historic names for them.

Creationism - POV, it reads like an essay rather than an encyclopedia article. Need help. silsor

February 11

Nose flute - raw text

Basil Brooke is a stub. Someone with Irish political history? Meelar

Chick Flick - POV list

Joseph Bologna - sub-stub. Bmills]

Psyduck - another pokemon sub-stub. Bmills

SMDS - sub stub. Bmills

Arbok - pokemon sub-stub. Bmills

Afghan Turkestan - very dated 1911. Bmills

Lake Como needs English-language usage, esp. last 'graph seemingly about using idioms that have no English equivalent i can think of.

Vegan (creature) existence/importance, nonsense?

  • Existence - yes, fictional as noted in article; importance - subjective, but I promise this is not self-promotional. A link to this entry has been replaced in the entry vegan in a more reasonable context.

February 6-10

Important Graphing Equations - naive math. Delete ?

LucasVarity - needs fmt, wikis, etc. maybe NPOVing. Bmills

Fartown - place description with no context, not even a country -- added some context--Mishac 04:16, 17 Feb 2004 (UTC)

Charles Herbert Allen - MoS - wikify. --MoS'ed and wikified. Gentgeen 08:52, 16 Feb 2004 (UTC)

Houston, Texas - excessively long, too many photos, takes entirely too long to load, too many long paragraphs that are unwikified. Needs to be broken up into multiple pages

February 9

Arabic literature only a bibliography of 2 books

Sequence points in Control flow. First edit I've made. I think it's in roughly the right place but needs a bit more work.

Parti Populaire des Putes - sub stub Bmills

Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church - copied from somewhere? Needs wikifying.

February 8

Sanjay Kumar - needs to be prosified

Andrea di Robilant - substub, unwikified

Real analysis, calculus - is a merge in order?

you're joking, right? - I don't claim to remember, but one of them says it's a name for the other. Jerzy - not a good idea, very different perspectives and likely readers Charles Matthews

Nagpur - one sentence +edit +wiki Mishac

Michael Corris just a bibliography

February 7

Aranes - was created as advertising vehicle for aranes.com, advert has been removed. Is this a real place?

National Revolutionary Army - sub-stub, possibly factually inaccurate

Furbo - real place, but needs a little work

Aquemini needs NPOVing from a hip hop fan.

were and wight both seemed trivial and/or nonsense to me. I have redirected wight to Isle of Wight, as any content it had seemed to duplicate material there; I propose to delete were in short order if no-one objects. + no obvious nonsense; copied the overwritten text of wight to Talk:Isle of Wight, in case it might inspire an addition to the corresponding article.

Battle of Jutland was Jellico considered a hero? needs overview section

image:Shuttle-enterprise.jpg This is actually a pic of Space Shuttle Endeavour. Could someone who knows anything about images rename it and find/fix all uses of it? -Move of images is not (yet?) possible, so need to re-upload with correct name.


Sandia National Laboratories - formatting +was a copyvio, rewritten into stub

February 6 Traditional medicine - essay needs complete overhaul Jwrosenzweig 22:50, 6 Feb 2004 (UTC) - Did minor editing. heidimo 03:53, 7 Mar 2004 (UTC)

Cost management, management accounting, maybe others (these are the only ones by User:81.248.9.34-- all selfpromotion added to normal article. a more qualified economist than I can weed out the dross, but as is it's BAD. -Sean 09:00, 6 Feb 2004 (UTC)

Computer-aided engineering Automated translation, probably from some website. Unreadable, unless you already know what it is. Mikkalai + rewritten; there's surely more to say. Catherine

Tai Chi Chuan needs NPOVing Meelar

KiddChris non wikified, accuracy check from someone in US? + for a radio personality he doesn't get very many Google hits [1]

February 4-5

Divine retribution - looks irredeemably awful from any point of view I can think of seglea

Lap joint - no text, just an svg file. (Do we even use svg here?) SVG is proposed. Anyway, this article is less than a day old. Give it some time.

Graffiti - is about graffiti art--merge w/graffiti art--and needs info on graffiti as problem; Graffiti art needs serious edit Elf

Ferdinando Provesi - copyedit, fact checking

Colligative properties needs rewrite for non-specialist +de-experted, now needs expansion ike9898 02:29, Feb 6, 2004 (UTC)

Impressment needs spelling, wikification, fact checking.

Propafenone - context needed

Zlotow - no article, just facts

Big Buddha - needs work

All for one, and one for all - keep or not to keep? Messy non wiki, saying.

Artistic computer game modification - mess

Tuna - embarrassingly stubby article. Tuna are not warm-blooded.

Pepsi ONE needs much more +some info about the artificial sweeter usedike9898

Negative resistance -- see my comment in talk:Negative resistance

School discipline -- hugely POV article, takes a U.S. pro-authority position - It's a copy straight from here - Move to Wikipedia:Possible copyright infringements then? - not copyvio, source states it is public domain - Started a new Stub, linked to discipline and put a NPOV message and statement about source all at top of article. Already in Wikipedia:Pages needing attention. kiwiinapanic

February 4 Eidolon -- principal deity of the twentieth century? Has anyone heard of this? - So last-century!

Santurce Crabbers (basketball) - nasty stub.

Zlotow County - needs wikification etc

Kinsky-horse - reads like a poor babelfish translation of de:Kinsky-Pferd (as do all the "Kinsky" articles). Needs someone fluent in German and English horse-speak! Lupo Slightly upgraded, but still needs work! +Sj+

Molly Brown House -sub stub

Walking like an Egyptian - fast-track for deletion? - VfD, by all means!!

Neuromodulators - needs some context. Bmills

Ugly Rumours - needs a complete rewrite. Bmills - Spoof text and image removed. User:Tony The Tiger added both of these, as well as adding nonsense to Tony Blair. All his edits need to be checked. Pete/Pcb21 (talk)

Maltese Nobility needs some serious formatting by someone who is good at that (ie, not me :-) ). As it looks copypasted, it might also need copyright-checking, but note that the original contributor seems to be the owner of www.maltagenealogy.com.

The Auteurs - british band. The article is more about Luke Haines, their front man... Lupo

Watch out for self promotion by 66.30.30.130. He's adding his own original research to articles.

Greek lexicon - written in first person, article includes comments, table needs alphabetization, additional data needs integration into table with greek translation, etc., etc...

Stimorol - mini-stub

Ancient philosophy - crap from long ago

February 1-3

Sport is a wordy, meandering contemplation of the concept. Needs sharper focus.

Communications management is an essay. Meelar

Janez Puhar needs context for what he did. Meelar

Video game industry practices. Unwikified

February 2 Aso Kumiko - just a list of awards +birthdate, filmography

Lonnie Jordan - fix or delete

Nazi human experimentation - need wikification and copyedit

Special:Contributions/130.88.96.65 - many POV edits related to Islam

Tim Girvin - vanity page? 300-some Google hits. Linked from The Evergreen State College. According to own website he was responsible for the design of the electronic version of EB. Explain importance or VfD.

February 1

Ray Stevens Collector's Series - is there more to this than just a track listing?

François-Michel Gonnot - expand, is he important?

Michael Corris - just references

Count Kinsky, Elena Ceausescu, Kinsky - work on English

Riot control -- NPOV'ed it ... but needs more; Needs Law enforcement informtaion ... JDR

air travel is a poor thing, which should either be dumped or properly linked to the innumerable places it could link to. seglea

Agnes Grey - stub at best

Wikipedia:Ignored feature requests - archiving needed

January 26-31

Bajirao needs NPOVing and wikifying.

Sportpalast speech - source text, no context

Gilad Sharon is a stub. Meelar

Federal Standard 1037C. Someone said "too many links to pages that shouldn't be created", but it's not obvious to me why. Nothing on Talk:Federal Standard 1037C, suggest more specific discussion there. Andrewa - They seem worth creating, but I sincerely doubt whether the links should be on the page. Andre Engels

Bretton Woods Conference. Probably now needs refactor by knowledgable person. See Talk:Bretton Woods.

Tiger Electronics little more than a picture

Bev Harris Does Harris warrant an article? Needs formatting help.

January 30

DNA binding protein list of 4 wikilinks

Blue-collar crime unwikified substub, could be interesting if well written Fabiform

Medieval warfare - good structure, no meat.

29 January

List of comic and cartoon characters. Needs merging. See talk page.

28 January

Biodynamic Agriculture - stub

List of civic, fraternal, service, and professional organizations - U.S.-centric. See the talk page. - Scooter

27 January

Ooststellingwerf, Stein, Netherlands, Elsloo, Train stations in the Netherlands - Both Ooststellingwerf and Stein (municipalities in the Netherlands) link to Elsloo as a town located within them. Elsloo redirects to Stein. Meanwhile, Train stations in the Netherlands also links to Elsloo, but which one? Can someone sort this out?

Turned Elsloo into a disambiguation page. Elsloo, Limburg and Elsloo, Friesland are redirects to their municipalities until someone decides to add articles for them. Linked Train stations in the Netherlands to Elsloo, Limburg (the station is called Beek-Elsloo, and Beek is also in Limburg). -- Kimiko 13:25, 2 Mar 2004 (UTC)

26 January

DXM - I've been working on this article significantly, it probably needs a NPOV edit from someone with less (clears throat) personal interest in the subject - we do NOT want to sound like WP is advocating abuse of DXM... Pakaran.

Beaumont Community, Oliver Close - expand? merge into Leyton?

Sant Cassia - need copyedit and enlargement

Reliability testing - needs lots of help

Inxire iO - reads like a sales brochure

January 20-25

Lagardere Active - sub stub

Conscientiology - religion?, science?, VfD? also Waldo Vieira, the inventor.

Brian Harvey - could use some help +stubbed, needs more content.

Luapula - Needs work

Wikipedia:Things to be moved to Wiktionary someone should transwiki all the entries, and the page can be redirected/deleted

January 24 The International Journal of Psychiatry - substub

Inpatient - dictionary

Ishy Bilady - a national anthem? orphaned and no google hits - United Arab Emirates links

23 January

Lachrymatory - stub. Bmills

Lumis and Umbra - needs lots of help. +done, but maybe vfd?

22 January 2004

The Breetles - formatting + are they famous? -435 google hits

Cristi Minculescu picture needs shrinking (don't know how myself) Fabiform

Sherwin Wine, Judith Seid - not about the subject

Jason Reso - is the article about the same person? anyone know prof. wrestling?

21 January 2004

Cf-pollable - needs clarifying

Asphodelus - just a taxobox

Disability rights movement - very stubby stub.

20 January 2004

User:Craigbutz has a long list of pages vocational students are working on -- many have been listed on VFD, most need serious help. All are linked from his user page. - Davodd

Institute of Cetacean Research - Needs work

Shirley Q. Liquor - was on VfD. See talk page.

LEFTOVERS

The following are sub-stubs:

The following are in need of formatting/wikilinking/encyclopedia-friendly language:

Other problems (should probably go to Wikipedia:Pages needing attention when removed):

  • Stippling - probably worth an entry, but certainly not this
  • March 1st Movement npov
  • Thin-film deposition very poor and not on the topics I would expect
  • Odalism - copyedit, NPOVing needed. And if there is a relation to neo-Nazis movements, it should be mentioned.
    • + copyedit, links improved, NPOV improved but the abstract stuff needs more help. Someone with better understanding of neo-Nazism could do much more.
  • GamesNET - needs verification
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:Cleanup&oldid=2804210"